Natural Rubber Latex vs Silicone: How to Choose a Pacifier Material

The pacifier material you choose will be one of the most important decisions you make when introducing your child to a pacifier. Medical grade silicone and natural rubber latex are the two most common materials used to make pacifiers. 

Every baby is different, so what worked for one might not work for another. Maybe your first born loved latex pacifiers but your new baby hates it. Maybe your mom friends swear by silicone pacifiers, but you can't get your baby on board.

Babies might reject a pacifier due to material, nipple shape, or even the mouth guard shape. They can be picky! If you want to learn about nipple shapes, check out our blog post all about it! Trying out different materials is a great place to start, so keep reading to learn more about the pros and cons of each type.

Frigg rubber pacifiers and frigg silicone pacifiers

Silicone Pacifiers: The Pros and Cons


  1. Easy to Clean: Silicone binkies are non-porous and smooth. They're easy to clean, sterilize, and don't harbor bacteria. Usually, they're dishwasher-safe, which is a huge plus for busy parents.
  2. Durable: Silicone tends to be more durable and long-lasting than latex. They're less likely to break down and deteriorate over time. You'll save money on replacements and won't stress about accidentally giving your kiddo a worn-out binky. They're also easier to store because they aren't vulnerable to light and moisture changes.
  3. Hypoallergenic: These pacies are less likely to cause allergic reactions than latex, making them a safer choice for babies with sensitive skin or allergies. If you're anxious about a potential latex allergy, consider trying silicone first.
  4. Odorless, Tasteless, and Toxin-Free: This is a neutral material that's tasteless, odorless, and toxin-free.
  5. Medical-Grade VS Food-Grade: You've probably seen these categories for silicone, but what do they mean? The labels indicate that the silicone has undergone testing and approval for use in food, like storage, or medical use, like sub-dermal implants. Both types are 100% safe and super gentle. No matter which you go with, you'll enjoy the same benefits.


  1. Firmer Texture: The durability of silicone pacies comes with a firmer, more rigid texture. Some babies may prefer a softer material, especially if they're used to softer mouth-feels like the breast or latex.
  2. Less natural feel: Silicone pacifiers don't have the same soft and flexible feeling as latex, which may be less comforting to some babies.
  3. Industrial Material: Silicone is totally safe and regulated, but if you prefer all-natural materials, then this might not be the best choice for you.

TIP: Silicone usually appears white or colorless. Natural rubber latex will appear yellower.

Latex Pacifiers: The Pros and Cons


  1. Soft and Flexible: Latex pacifiers have a soft and flexible texture. They feel more like the breast and provide comfort for babies.
  2. Natural Material: Many parents prefer latex binkies because they're made of all natural rubber. They're usually better for the environment.
  3. Easier Transition: Babies who have difficulty transitioning from breast to pacifier may have an easier time with the natural feel of the latex paci.


  1. Prone to Wear and Tear: Because latex is a natural material, it will naturally break down over time. They're more prone to wear and tear, so you must check the paci before you give it to your little one. You'll also replace them more often. 
  2. Harder to Clean: Latex is a porous material, which means it can harbor bacteria and germs if not cleaned properly. They require a bit more upkeep than silicone.
  3. Potential Allergic Reactions: Latex allergies are relatively uncommon but can occur in babies. If your little one has a latex allergy or sensitive skin, then try starting with silicone first.

child with bibs pacifier

Which Pacifier Material is Right for Your Baby?

The choice between silicone and latex pacifiers ultimately comes down to your baby's preferences and any specific concerns you may have. Every baby is different, so don't be afraid to try out a few different options to see what works best for your little one.

If you're looking for durability, ease of cleaning, and hypoallergenic properties, consider a silicone pacifier. If you prefer a softer, more natural material, then latex pacifiers will be a great fit. Whichever you choose, be sure to inspect it regularly for wear and tear, clean it properly, and replace as needed.

Making sure your baby feels safe, comforted, and loved is the most important thing, whether they're sucking on a silicone or latex pacifier. Happy binky shopping!

Leave a comment